The Pittsburgh Donahue family has reset its sales strategy for Gordon Pointe, a nine-acre waterfront compound in Naples, Florida. After nearly two years on the market without a buyer at $295 million, the estate is now offered as four parcels for a combined $271 million, giving buyers the option to purchase only selected pieces.
Key takeaways
The revised approach lowers the total price and allows buyers to pursue different parts of the property.
- The four parcels have a combined asking price of $271 million, down $24 million from the original price.
- The Gulf-front residence and its 5.39-acre parcel are listed for $195 million.
- The listing agent says three qualified prospective buyers are considering the estate in different configurations.
Four parcels, one estate
Gordon Pointe includes a principal home on the Gulf of Mexico, two guest houses overlooking Naples Bay and a private yacht basin. The beachfront parcel is listed at $195 million. Two bayfront parcels are priced at $35 million and $31 million, while the yacht basin is offered separately for $10 million.
The family’s preferred outcome remains a single buyer who would keep the compound intact, according to listing agent Timothy Savage. But the separate prices are intended to make the property’s value easier to assess and potentially attract buyers interested in only the beach, bayfront lots or boating facilities.
Buyers weigh different options
Savage said one prospective buyer is considering the full estate, another is looking at the bay parcels and yacht basin, and an investment group is assessing the property for redevelopment. He described the split marketing strategy as effective in helping buyers understand the options.
The estate first went on the market in February 2024 for $295 million. At that price, a sale would have surpassed the U.S. residential-property record of $239.96 million, paid by investor Ken Griffin for a Manhattan penthouse in 2019. Ultra-luxury homes can take multiple seasons to sell, given the small pool of buyers able to purchase them.
A family gathering place
Gordon Pointe became the Donahue family’s Florida gathering place over decades. John Donahue, co-founder of Pittsburgh-based investment firm Federated Investors, and his wife, Rhodora, raised 13 children. Their extended family eventually grew to more than 300 people, and the compound was designed to host large gatherings, with space for more than 100 overnight guests.
John Donahue died in 2017 and Rhodora in 2022. The family put the estate up for sale after their deaths, but relatives have continued to use it while it remains on the market. Federated Investors later combined with British firm Hermes Fund Managers in 2018 to form Federated Hermes, an international asset manager headquartered in Pittsburgh.
- Pittsburgh’s Donahue family cuts price on spectacular $295 million Florida estate, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
