October pending home sales dropped sharply, raising the possibility that the housing market has reached the bottom of its current cycle. The National Association of REALTORS® said the decline could mark a turning point if mortgage rates have peaked, but persistent affordability pressures may instead mean more would-be buyers are giving up on homeownership.
Key takeaways
- Pending sales fell 4.7% from September and 16.7% from a year earlier.
- Contract signings declined month over month and year over year in every U.S. region.
- NAR’s chief economist said October may be the cycle’s low point, but cautioned that demand could also be weakening.
- Two consecutive months of record-low pending contracts point to a sluggish fourth quarter.
A possible turning point — or a deeper slowdown
Pending sales measure home purchases under contract but not yet completed, making them an early indicator of future existing-home sales. NAR Chief Economist Lawrence Yun said October could prove to be the low point for contract activity as mortgage rates appear to have peaked. But he also raised a less optimistic possibility: that homeownership is becoming unaffordable for more Americans, limiting the pool of potential buyers.
Yun said the recent run of record-low pending contracts suggests fourth-quarter closings could be very weak. He added that existing-home sales for the full year could fall to their lowest level since the mid-1990s.
Declines spread across the country
Every region recorded fewer contract signings than in the previous month and the same period a year earlier. First American Financial Senior Economist Sam Williamson pointed to affordability as a common challenge for buyers. The South and West each posted monthly declines of more than 6%, while the Midwest fell nearly 3% and the Northeast changed only slightly. Year-over-year, every region was down by double digits, with the West declining about 20%.
The broad-based pullback suggests that weakness is not confined to one local market. Even areas that have performed relatively well recently saw sales activity contract.
Markets with comparatively smaller declines
Among the metro areas cited for smaller drops were Cincinnati, down 4.7%; Austin, Texas, down 9.7%; and Hartford, Connecticut, down 10%. Indianapolis and Chicago followed, with declines of 11.3% and 11.9%, respectively. Pittsburgh, Nashville, Buffalo, Jacksonville and Cleveland also appeared among the markets with comparatively modest decreases, each reporting declines between 12.4% and 12.8%.
These figures still point to falling contract activity, rather than growth. Whether October proves to be a floor will depend in part on mortgage-rate trends and whether buyers can overcome ongoing affordability barriers.
