Broward County property owners are facing a perplexing situation where a slight reduction in the millage rate is overshadowed by soaring property values, leading to increased tax bills. This has ignited significant concern and reaction among homeowners, many of whom are struggling to keep up with the escalating costs.
Key Takeaways
- Broward County lowered its millage rate for the first time since 2018, but property tax bills are still rising due to increased property values.
- A recent audit of Broward County’s finances by the Florida Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) was announced shortly before the millage rate decision.
- Homeowners like Walter and Debbie Priebe saw their property taxes jump from $15,000 to over $90,000 annually after renovations triggered a full property reassessment.
- Florida law mandates market-based assessments after substantial improvements, potentially removing protections like the Save Our Homes cap.
- A surge in all-cash offers from out-of-state buyers has significantly driven up home prices and, consequently, property tax assessments.
The Paradox of Lower Millage Rates
The Broward County Commission recently voted to decrease its millage rate from 5.6690% to 5.6658%. This marks the first reduction since 2018. However, this seemingly positive move is being undermined by continuously rising property values. The small millage rate decrease results in a reduction of just over $1 million from the nearly $2 billion generated from property taxes, a figure dwarfed by the impact of increased property valuations.
A Homeowner’s Financial Shock
The stark reality of these rising taxes is exemplified by the case of Walter and Debbie Priebe. After purchasing their Pompano Beach home in 2002, they undertook significant renovations, including fixing termite damage and adding a second story. While they anticipated a tax increase, they were blindsided when their annual property tax bill skyrocketed from $15,000 to over $90,000 in 2023. This dramatic increase was triggered by the renovations, which led to a full reassessment of their property’s value, pushing it from an initial purchase price of $650,000 to an assessed value of over $4.4 million.
Understanding Florida’s Property Tax Laws
Florida law has specific provisions regarding property taxes. The homestead exemption can reduce the taxable value of a primary residence by up to $50,000, and the Save Our Homes cap limits annual increases in assessed value. However, substantial improvements to a property, such as expansions or major structural changes, can trigger a full reassessment at just value (market value), potentially nullifying these protections. This means that renovations, even with sentimental value, can lead to a property being treated as new construction, resetting its assessed value to current market rates.
The Impact of Market Dynamics
The surge in property values is also attributed to a significant increase in all-cash offers, particularly from out-of-state buyers. This trend, exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic, has created a highly competitive housing market. Homes are selling for record prices, and appraisers must factor these high-value sales into their assessments, further driving up property tax burdens for existing homeowners. While rising home equity is generally positive, it can become a significant financial strain when coupled with unaffordable property tax increases.
Calls for Reform
Stories like the Priebes’ have fueled calls for property tax reform. Governor Ron DeSantis has expressed support for exploring measures to alleviate the burden on homeowners, even suggesting the possibility of eliminating property taxes altogether, though such a proposal faces significant challenges given their role in funding local services. For many residents, the current situation is unsustainable, threatening their ability to remain in their homes.